TL;DR — Quick Summary
- 22 states now ban or restrict credit card surcharging in 2026 — up from 10 in 2023 — creating a complex compliance landscape that ISOs must understand to protect their merchants.
- Merchants in surcharging-permitted states can legally pass credit card fees to customers, potentially reducing processing costs by 50-100%, but violations carry fines of $2,500-$25,000 per transaction in some states.
- ISOs who proactively advise merchants on state-specific surcharging rules build trust and differentiate from processors who leave merchants to navigate compliance alone.
The Surprising History of Credit Card Surcharging
For decades, credit card surcharging was a legal gray area that most merchants avoided. Then, in 2013, a court settlement between major card networks and retailers — combined with subsequent regulatory changes — opened the door for merchants in most states to legally add a fee to credit card transactions.
The rules vary dramatically by state. Some states have enacted explicit bans on surcharging (primarily to protect consumers). Others allow it with strict disclosure requirements. And some have no restrictions at all. For ISOs, understanding this patchwork of rules is essential — your merchants rely on you to guide them through the legal minefield of credit card surcharging.
As of 2026, 22 states have enacted laws that ban or significantly restrict credit card surcharging — more than double the 10 states that had restrictions in 2023. This rapid expansion is driven by consumer advocacy groups lobbying state legislatures, citing confusion and unfairness when merchants add fees at the point of sale.
The Complete State-by-State Guide for 2026
States Where Surcharging Is Completely Banned
Eight states have enacted laws that prohibit merchants from adding any surcharge to credit card transactions. In these states, merchants who attempt to surcharge face fines ranging from $2,500 to $10,000 per violation:
- California — California Civil Code Section 1748.9 prohibits credit card surcharges. Violations are subject to civil penalties of up to $2,500 per violation plus attorney fees. Note: California does allow cash discounts.
- Colorado — Colorado Revised Statutes prohibit surcharges on credit card transactions. The law has been challenged but remains in effect as of 2026.
- Connecticut — Connecticut consumer protection law prohibits surcharging. Merchants offering cash discounts is the permitted alternative.
- Florida — Florida Statutes prohibit credit card surcharges. This has been litigated extensively but remains law. Fines up to $10,000 per violation.
- Kansas — Kansas has had a surcharge prohibition since 1985, one of the oldest in the country.
- Maine — Maine’s law prohibits merchants from adding surcharges to credit card transactions.
- Massachusetts — Massachusetts General Laws explicitly prohibit surcharging, though cash discounts are permitted.
- New York — New York’s General Business Law prohibits credit card surcharges. Cash discounts remain legal. Notably, the New York law has survived multiple court challenges.
States with Significant Restrictions
Fourteen additional states have restrictions that fall short of full bans — typically limiting surcharge amounts, requiring specific disclosures, or restricting which card types can be surcharged:
- Arizona, Ohio, Texas — Allow surcharging but cap the amount at the merchant’s actual interchange cost or a set percentage (typically 2-3%).
- Virginia, Washington — Require prominent disclosure of surcharges at the point of entry and on receipts.
- Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Wisconsin — Have enacted various restrictions including disclosure requirements, prohibition on surcharging debit cards, or limits on surcharge amounts.
States Where Surcharging Is Fully Permitted
The remaining 28+ states have no state-level restrictions on credit card surcharging. Merchants in these states may surcharge, subject to network rules and federal disclosure requirements.
| State | Surcharge Status | Cash Discount | Key Rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| California | Banned | Permitted | Fines up to $2,500/violation |
| New York | Banned | Permitted | Survived multiple court challenges |
| Florida | Banned | Permitted | Fines up to $10,000/violation |
| Texas | Restricted | Permitted | Surcharge capped at cost |
| Nevada | Permitted | Permitted | Full freedom with disclosure |
Network Rules vs. State Laws: The Federal Framework
Understanding surcharging requires understanding the two-layer legal framework: federal/network rules and state laws.
Federal and Network Rules (Apply Nationwide)
- Surcharges must be the same for all credit cards of the same network (Visa, Mastercard, etc.)
- Surcharges cannot exceed the merchant’s cost of accepting that card type (typically 1.5-3.5%)
- Merchants must prominently disclose surcharges before the customer completes the transaction
- Surcharge must be displayed as a separate line item on the receipt
- Debit cards cannot be surcharged under Visa and Mastercard rules
State Laws (Vary Significantly)
State laws layer additional restrictions on top of federal rules. In states with bans, merchants cannot surcharge regardless of what federal rules permit. In states with restrictions, merchants may surcharge but must comply with state-specific requirements.
The Cash Discount Strategy: A Legal Workaround
For merchants in states that prohibit surcharging, the cash discount strategy is the most common workaround. The concept is simple: rather than adding a fee to credit card transactions, the merchant offers a discount for cash payments.
Legally, this works because most state surcharge bans explicitly permit cash discounts. The merchant posts a “cash price” and a “card price” at the point of sale. Customers paying with cash pay the lower cash price; customers paying with cards pay the higher card price.
The key distinction courts have upheld: a cash discount is a reduction from a standard price, not an addition to a credit card price. This semantic difference is legally significant in most states.
Common Surcharging Mistakes That Lead to Fines
- Surcharging debit cards: Both Visa and Mastercard rules prohibit surcharging on debit transactions, regardless of state law.
- Not disclosing fees upfront: Even in permitted states, failing to display the surcharge before the transaction completes is a network rules violation.
- Incorrect fee amounts: Surcharges must not exceed the merchant’s actual cost of accepting that card type. Overcharging is both a network and state law violation.
- Applying surcharges selectively: In states that permit surcharging, you cannot surcharge some customers and not others for the same card type.
How OrderPin Helps ISOs Guide Merchants on Surcharging Compliance
State-Specific Compliance Rules
OrderPin’s platform includes built-in state-by-state surcharging rules, automatically flagging prohibited states and helping merchants configure compliant cash discount programs.
Built-In Cash Discount Programs
For merchants in prohibited states, OrderPin supports automated cash discount programs that comply with state law while reducing credit card processing costs.
Real-Time Violation Alerts
OrderPin’s POS flags potential surcharging violations in real time — before they result in fines. Protect your merchants from costly compliance mistakes.
How ISOs Can Turn Surcharging Compliance Into a Selling Point
Most payment processors leave merchants to navigate surcharging rules on their own. This is a mistake — and an opportunity. ISOs who proactively educate merchants on surcharging compliance build trust, reduce merchant risk, and differentiate from commodity processors.
Your role as an ISO: Help merchants understand (1) whether they can surcharge in their state, (2) what disclosures are required, (3) how to configure their POS correctly, and (4) how cash discount programs can achieve similar cost savings in prohibited states.
This is not a one-time conversation. With 22 states now having restrictions (up from 10 in 2023), state laws are changing frequently. ISOs who stay current on surcharging legislation and proactively update their merchant base will be seen as compliance partners — not just payment providers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can merchants surcharge American Express cards?
Yes, in most cases. American Express has historically had stricter anti-surcharging rules, but following the 2012 settlement with retailers, American Express now allows surcharging on American Express cards — subject to the same rules as Visa and Mastercard (same surcharge for all Amex cards, cannot exceed actual cost, must be disclosed). However, always check the current American Express merchant agreement as terms can change.
Can merchants surcharge online transactions differently than in-person?
Yes, surcharging rules generally apply differently to e-commerce vs. in-person transactions. For in-person transactions, surcharges must be disclosed at the point of sale (signage, menu notation, etc.). For e-commerce, surcharges must be disclosed before the customer completes checkout. State laws vary in their application to e-commerce — some states’ surcharge bans apply to all transactions regardless of channel. Always check state-specific rules for your merchant’s situation.
What happens if a merchant accidentally surcharges in a prohibited state?
Consequences vary by state. In California, violations carry civil penalties of up to $2,500 per violation plus attorney fees. In Florida, fines can reach $10,000 per violation. Beyond state fines, card networks (Visa, Mastercard) also impose penalties for surcharge rule violations — potentially including merchant account termination. If a merchant accidentally starts surcharging in a prohibited state, they should stop immediately, refund any surcharge fees collected, and consult with a payment compliance attorney.
Do cash discount programs work in all states?
Cash discount programs are permitted in most states, but not all. Some states that prohibit surcharging have been interpreted to also restrict cash discounts if the “discount” is effectively a disguised surcharge. The legal landscape varies and continues to evolve. Currently, cash discounts are most clearly protected in states like California and New York where the laws explicitly carve out cash discounts as an exception. In states with broader restrictions, consult a payment attorney before implementing a cash discount program.
How much can merchants save with surcharging?
In states where surcharging is permitted, merchants who surcharge credit cards at 2-3% effectively eliminate their credit card processing costs on those transactions. For a restaurant processing $500,000/year in credit card volume at 2.5% interchange, surcharging could save $12,500/year in processing costs — or more if the surcharge is set at market rates rather than cost-plus. However, the revenue impact depends on customer behavior: some customers will pay the surcharge, others may switch to cash or choose a competitor.
Conclusion
Credit card surcharging is legal in most U.S. states, but the compliance landscape is more complex than ever. With 22 states now restricting surcharging — up from 10 in 2023 — ISOs who understand the rules can help merchants save thousands of dollars in processing fees while avoiding costly compliance violations.
The key is proactive guidance. Merchants need to know: (1) can they surcharge in their state, (2) what disclosures are required, (3) how to configure their POS correctly, and (4) how cash discount programs can provide an alternative in restricted states.
ISOs who provide this guidance build trust and differentiate from processors who leave merchants to figure it out alone. With fines of $2,500 to $25,000 per violation in some states, merchants are increasingly willing to pay for a processor who keeps them compliant.
OrderPin’s white-label POS platform includes built-in state-by-state surcharging compliance tools, automated cash discount programs, and real-time violation alerts — helping ISOs protect their merchants and build lasting relationships based on trust and compliance expertise.
About OrderPin
OrderPin is a white-label POS platform for ISO and MSP partners. Our surcharging compliance tools help ISOs guide merchants through state-specific rules, automate cash discount programs, and avoid costly violations.
Learn more about OrderPin’s compliance tools
